Analising
Digital Journalism: Information,
communication and technology
Joan
Francesc Cánovas *
1.
Introduction
With
the recent explosion in the supply of interactive
multimedia, there has been a devastating increase
of communication studies; the focus has been
primarily on the audience for
computer-based media forms, particularly on the
uses and effects of these new media. This is
where we will try to add some specific, hopefully
valuable information. Our field of study is the
critical evaluation of websites with a extensive
journalistic content; while we focus on countries
close to the Netherlands, namely: the
Netherlands, Belgium, Germany, Austria,
Luxembourg and Switzerland. We combed the net for
sites, coughed up important criteria needed for
the critical evaluation and thought of a way to
expose the best sites by thorough calculation,
trying to be as complete as possible. In the
progress we also thought of how to tie an honest
and true conclusion to our findings. First I will
describe how we structured our project.
2.
Working Procedure
Combing the
net:
After the first
session together we started off with the
occupation of nine computers in our school
building, getting connected to that virtual world
and letting different search-engines loose on
search strings like: "news AND topical AND
politics". The first functional selection
choosing sites to evaluate, were liable to the
fundamental criteria we all agreed on. These
were:
- General
Approaches on media and journalism:
ethical, critical, plural, authentic and
related to rigorous news;
- Fundamental
Contents Selection of the online media:
without reproduction in a conventional
media, without topical material, without
fiction and with primary a European
audience. Arguably with a possibility of
being read in different languages.
Sites with for example a tabloid related
content were the first ones to drop out,
for obvious reasons. We also skipped
sites that were too general: mainly
because when sites focus too much on the
variety of information, this usually is
at the expense of the overall quality of
information. We also left out sites that
are locally oriented. We considered they
would have too little european
appeal to ever make it to the final
top ten and as on-line versions of
smaller newspapers they seem to spend
less effort (manpower) to make their
sites really competitive.
After a couple of days trying to find
sites in every corner of this virtual
community, we summed up a list of forty
sites ready for the actual evaluation.
Criteria used
for evaluation:
After a couple
of group sessions, where we discussed what we
thought a medium like the internet could add to
the journalistic outlets (1), we decided that we
could divide our criteria in three broad
categories: information, communication and
technology or ICT(2).
1 See also: B.L.
Massey and M.R. Levy,
"Interactivity, On-line Journalism,
and English-Language Web Newspapers in
Asia", Journalism & Mass
Communication Quarterly, Vol. 76,
No.1, Spring 1999, 138-151.
2 Thanks to Wijnand Aalderink,
a teacher in digital journalism who
joined one of our discussions. |
- Information
(content): this was a subject our group
had quite different opinions about, and
still has. The offered information is
always subjected to differing
interpretations. We all have our own
ideas on what or whether journalism has a
specific goal, purpose or meaning. We
agreed to form criteria around the basic
rules of journalism, which in general
means presenting the public a truthful,
topical, pluralistic, reliable and
complete view of a certain subject.
Regardless what kind of information
were talking about because
news comes in different
forms. Our criteria on information
therefore were: Hearing both sides;
mention of sources, Use of the 5 Ws
and context and finally when the site has
updated last. Each criteria is subjected
to judgements: bad, moderate, reasonable,
good and very good.
- Communication
(interactivity): here we were quite
unanimous. We decided to judge the site
on how and whether it had a possibility
for the public to react to stories,
opinions etc. And in which form the site
offered this opportunity. The criteria
were; personal profiles, a
discussion-forum and email to editors.
- With a personal
profile we mean the possibility to get
your own information or content customised
and sent to your email account. While we
combed the web many of us ran into sites
using this application and saw this as an
efficient way of spreading information.
- The thought behind a discussion-forum
is very simple, though important. The main
shortcoming of printed journalism is that
its a hassle to really discuss certain
subjects/stories with the staff or other
people with shared interests. Heres
where the Internet proves itself very useful.
It offers an easy way of speaking your mind
and getting in contact with the people
responsible for the written story.
Web-communities are bound to form around
people with shared interests, and
theres where journalism can study the
impact of news. Very interesting.
- Emailing to editors creates a more
functional binding with the audience. The
question rises if the staff takes the effort
to respond.
- Technique
(form/layout): Since the Internet
provides the possibility to get your
information spread all over the world,
multilingualism seemed an important
criteria. The problem is finding a site,
which actually thinks the same. The
layout had various ways of keeping an
audience committed to a site and can
therefore be effective and efficient. A
site should have a very clear and logical
outlook, not too flashy but colourful and
inviting. We decided to judge the sites
on various layout criteria;
Multilingualism, moving images, sounds,
infographics, graphics, Surveyability,
layout, navigation, Userfriendlyness,
orientation and the possibility to search
either the site or the Internet.
- Multilingualism;
if the site offers their information in
different languages it proves itself
professional. Mainly in areas where the
English language is not common. Usually the
majority of the surfing crowd is familiar
with the English language but the Internet is
growing fast including the people who only
speak their national language. Its
therefore important for sites with
journalistic content to serve the growing
Internet population. Arguably theres a
difficulty here; the aim of the site, and how
to judge that.
- Moving images: One of the many
additionals of the I-media not possible with
printed media. It definitely depends where
the images are used for, and with what
intent. Usually the commercials are the
moving parts that draw the actual attention,
sometimes the site itself has a sort of
info-graphic making use of moving parts.
- Sounds; well the original intent of
this specific criterium is whether the site
offers an online radio or tv-type content to
listen to or watch. But in our evaluation
district we only ran into one site making use
of this possibility. The reason we chose this
criterium was that many American journalistic
sites use the possibility for folks to listen
to online speeches of writers, activists,
newsitems, etc. We thought of this as very
effective use of I-media and possible impact
on people. Unfortunately its not
recognised yet.
- Infographics; we talked about this
before. Very useful tool and fortunately many
sites use it.
- Graphics; with the judgement of
graphics used in the site we generally mean
the design and colour scheme. We found it
very crucial that sites use inviting and nice
colours to soothe the eye. Important when
reading long parts and searching for
information.
- Surveyability; judging how
intelligible the main-page offers the
content. The ultimate surveyability is a
sitemap. A sitemap provides a very clear
summary of the overall site and adds to the
comprehensibility. It proves itself a very
important criterium because when you enter a
site for the first time not finding your way
around, you quickly move on.
- Layout; very much related to the
surveyability and graphics. The site should
have a well first impression and the layout
is very much involved in this. Specifically
about where certain caterns, possibilities,
site-extras, links, specials, etc. are placed
and to what extent theyre presented.
Pictures play a big role; where to place
them, how big, how many, etc.
- Navigation: "where can you get
from the main-page", is the main
question here. Navigation bars and their
complexibility differ strongly from page to
page. Its crucial to have a clear
navigational system which allows the user to
choose what, where, which and whether to find
information on the site. Close related to
orientation.
- Orientation; every moment while
youre connected to a site you need to
know where you are and how to get back. It is
crucial to the quality of a site. Users bug
off when its not clear how and where
they surf.
Category 1
Least important criteria.
Multiplying factor: 1 |
Category 2
Important criteria.
Multiplying factor: 2 |
Category 3
Very important criteria.
Multiplying factor: 3 |
- e-mail with
editors
- moving images
- sounds
|
- last update
- personal profile
- multilingual
- info-graphics
- graphics
- lay out
- orientation
|
- hearing both sides
- Mention of sources
- Use of 5 Ws
+ context
- Forum
- Survey-ability
- Navigation
- Possibility to
search
|
Category 1
| E-mail
with editors: |
We didnt find this
criteria particularly important because
of the fact that all sites have this
option. There was some discussion weather
we should check the response time of this
option. But regarding the amount of time
we can invest in this project we decided
to leave this aspect out. |
| Moving
images: |
They look nice but they do
not actually add anything to the
journalistic qualities of the site.
Besides, after a while they get annoying. |
| Sounds: |
Same as above. |
Category 2
| Last
update: |
We think the updates
should be as resent as possible because
you need the most actual information. |
| Personal
profile: |
As you visit a site you
get a lot of information you dont
need. Therefor it is important that you
are able to make a selection of the news
that you want to reed. |
| Multilingual: |
Because we are working on
a project that reviews sites al over
Europe, we think it is of some relevance
that the site can be viewed in more than
one language. But as there are a lot of
good sites around, aimed at only one
country, we decided not to put it in
category 3 but in category 2. |
| Info-graphics: |
Internet is an excellent
medium to use info-graphics for making
clear what you want to say, when we say
this we re thinking about things as
maps, statistics, etc. |
| Lay
out: |
The lay out can make or
brake a site. When a site looks good,
people will take interest in it and read
it. But as we think it does not actually
add anything to the journalistic
qualities of the site we put it in
category 2. |
| Orientation: |
It is important to know
where you are on a site because you must
be able to find your way trough the huge
amount of information to find exactly
what you were looking for. |
Category 3
| Hearing
both sides: |
To ensure the journalistic
qualities of the site, you must be able
to find multiple opinions on the
subjects. We dont want to promote
someones personal agenda. |
| Mention
of sources: |
Anyone can put their
opinion on the net that doesnt make
it journalism. So you have to know where
its coming from. |
Use
of five Ws
+ example: |
Its important that
an article is written with the use of
Where, Why, When, Who, What and off
course How to ensure you get everything
you need to know. |
| Forum: |
A forum is very important
to get a more personal touch with the
people who are visiting your site. You
ask a question and they give an answer. |
| Survey-ability: |
How easy is it for a user
to find the information on the site that
they need. Because of the use of clear
hits you can make a site easier to use
for the customers. Survey-ability comes
together with navigation and
user-friendliness. |
| Navigation: |
When you have entered a
hit on the site, you still have to see
where you are on the site and how you can
get back again to the Home Page. When
this is easy to do the navigation is all
right. |
| Possibility
to search: |
There is too much
information on the site. You want to get
to that little piece of information. What
do you do? You fill in your search-word
and there you have it, good luck with it
and see you next time. |
Results: The Dutch Top
10
Scores of the
sites subdivided in information (contents),
communication (interactivity) and techniques
(lay-out). Now you can see in which individual
category the site scored lots of points and in
which it did not. As can be seen there was not
much of a difference between the sites within the
comunication criteria. Except for one
site they all contained the three aspects of
interactivity we distinguished. Differences were
made on the information (content) and the
technique (form/lay-out) criteria. Please note
that the winner distinguished itself
on especially on information (content), but that
the number two did best on the technique
(form/lay-out) criteria. Also note that all
on-line media could still be improved from the
technical point of view.
1. www.diewelt.de - Die Welt
Die Welt is a German newspaper site, which is
updated several times a day. The site is more
than complete and handles just about everything
important in Germany and in the rest of the
world. The lay out again is very modern and the
articles are written for the Internet. You can
read an article in two minutes or so and
thats what the Internet needs. Remarkable
is that die Welt gives a lot of opportunities to
discuss news issues. The file on the wall in
Germany is very interesting because of the chosen
approach. The presence of a News ticker helps you
to keep up to date while reading articles. The
archive works tremendously well. Its fast
and easy to use. You dont have to be an
expert in making up search words.
2. www.nu.nl - Nu
Nu.nl is not a site based on a newspaper,
because of that it is unique in our top 10.
Hearing both sides is done very well, the
articles are well written and the subjects are
very innovative. The articles arent too
long, so that makes it very suitable for the
Internet. There are a lot of hits on the site.
The lay out is modern and user-friendly. The
possibility to watch the Internet-journal is not
seen before. The site is updated once a day,
which is a weak point. There are several sites
that update their site more than once a day. A
lot of attention is given to the Economic Page.
Nu.nl keeps a lot of files with actual issues.
They are very complete and easy to get.
3. www.volkskrant.nl - De Volkskrant
De Volkskrant is a Dutch newspaper and has a
national reach. Over the whole it is seen in
Holland as one of the best newspapers of the
country. The Internet-version looks at first
sight a bit boring. But when you get into the
site deeper you discover many wonderful things.
Hearing both sides is done very well on the site,
just like the newspaper. Our comment on the site
is just that the survey-ability is not as clear
as it is done at for example styria.co.at. The
hits are not well described. For example the hit
"in druk", meaning
"Published" is not clear enough. The
newspaper is famous for its enclosures,
its strange that on the site this element
doesnt catch the eye. Theyre even
hard to find. Its good to see de Volkskrant
cut back the length of its articles. The layout
is sober and not very modern. The vertical layout
is to be found at the bottom of the site. This
means you have scroll all the way down to get to
some links. This is very irritating. On both
sides are quite prominent ads to be seen.
They are moving ones and catch the eye in an
unpleasant way. Nevertheless the site has got a
nice forum. A personal profile is missing. The
files are very nice and complete. When you are
making an essay on a subject, check this one out!
4. www.styria.co.at - Styria
Whats very nice about Styria.co.at is
that they got a hot-link with Kleine on-line.
Information from both sides is within reach with
only one button. The information on Styria, by
the way an Austrian news site, is complete and
handles mainly about politics in Austria and
Germany. We discussed this site in a meeting,
because they have got a hot link to the
FPÖ-site. But because other sites are mentioned
as well we think its not a problem. Very
complete, very affective in search and a lot of
hits and links. The only thing about Styria is
that the Layout is very old-fashioned. The site
is updated more times a day.
5. www.nrc.nl - NRC
The NRC Handelsblad is a renowned
newspaper in Holland and was one the first
newspapers in Holland who started offering an
electronic version of their paper. Unfortunately
their site show many resemblances with the
printed version. At first sight its nothing
more than the written version on a computer
screen. However we regard the site as specific
for the Internet, because the site is updated at
least twice a day. There is a possibility to
discuss with the other readers. The NRC has
a decent archive and very easy and effective in
its use. They offer good links to the
latest news and on the welcome-page they offer
links to files, made by the NRC, which are
related to the latest developments in the news.
The introduction texts on the welcome-page are
well written and very short. The articles self
are of good quality, but they are maybe a bit too
long for the Internet. We conclude that the NRC
on the net is just an improved and updated
version of their written version, but a damn good
one. Still the use of moving images, sound and
info-graphics should make this site even better.
The articles are sometimes written too long. The
Internet user does not read long articles.
Its much better to use links.
6. www.berlinonline.de - Berlin Online3
The Berlin Online is a joint venture
of the Berliner Zeitung, Berlin Magazin,
Berlin Abendblatt and the Berlin Kurier. The
site gives you the opportunity to read the
written versions of the four named before, but
there is more. The site is very up to date.
Almost every hour articles and news-items are
edited to the page. There is also a Newstickers,
like most German sites have, that shows what the
latest news is. Only the layout is a true
disaster. It seems that nobody in Berlin knows
how a photo-camera works. Absolutely no pictures
on this site and moving images are complete abacadabra
for the people of Berlin Online.
7. www.stern.de - Stern3
Stern is a German magazine which is
quite popular. Its quite sensational and
you rather find Britney Spears instead of Tony
Blair on their front cover. The online-version of
the Stern does not only offer you the
articles, which already appeared in the printed
version, they also give you the latest news. News
thats packed in short and good written
articles. The welcome page of the site gives you
very good summary of the news and articles. If
you want to know more about the subject just
click on the word mehr and the site will
navigate you in a second to that particular
subject. Maybe you also like to know that the
site is updated at least once a day and that the
site is hosted by some webreporters. These
journalists write just only about the web and we
have to admit their articles are very refreshing.
On the 18th of November, for example, one of the webreporters
wrote about a certain wine-site. He didnt
only describe the site, but he also tasted the
wines that were recommended on this site. So
thats what you calling practising what you
preach. The lay out of the site is very
easy-going. The colours that are used are very
natural. So that makes it very comfortable to
take a quick glance through the site. Besides the
articles Stern also offers hundreds of
other services. If you want a car, a job
or a second wife. Then Stern is your site.
But if thats not what you are looking for.
Then you can go wild in the different forums,
chat-rooms etc on the site and every day there is
the inevitable question of the day.
Stern offers more Internet extras. Such as a
newsletter which everybody can subscribe to.
There is a possibility to play a game if
youre tired of reading and there is also a Stern-TV.
After seeing all these extras. After reading all
the quality-articles. After watching all those
dazzling images. What else could we do than give
this site a top-ten ranking?
8. www.webwereld.nl - Webwereld3
Webwereld is a news site without a printed
version. The Dutch site handles just about
everything hot in the computer world. To make it
clearer: its a very global site. Despite
the fact that the layout sucks, the site came in
our top 10. Well tell you why. The main
reason is that just about everything. The forum
is very complete and asks a lot of the customers.
The site has got almost everything known in the
interactive world. You can have your own
telephone file on the site, secured with a
password. This site has got so much links that
you would need a day to check the complete site.
Because of the bad layout and there is only
information about computer-stuff the site
didnt became a top 3. The personal profile
is very complete. The articles written about
computers are easy to understand for everyone.
The survey-ability is lousy, navigation the same.
9. www.wiwo.de - Wirtschaftswoche
Wirtschaftswoche is a human-interest site
from Germany. Its very complete and primary
handles on politics and economy. The articles on
the site are nicely written. The subjects are
very original and many times show a different
side of the story, the so-called background
stories. The layout is a bit crowded and boring.
Nevertheless the survey-ability is well taken
care of. A nice extra service is their personal
travel agency. Unfortunately there are not much
useful links for the reader to find out more.
They have got a personal profile and their forum
is very complete. We like the possibility given
on the Homepage to read further, when you want
to. This means that the articles are not too long
and when you need more information you can simply
get it by pushing one tiny button.
10. www.rz-online.de - Rhein zeitung
Rhein Zeitung is a newspaper site with also a
printed version. The German site handles mostly
about popular subjects such as movies, theatre
and sport. Off course theyve got some news
hits but over the whole its more a
sensational newspaper. The layout is very modern
and smart. Smart because when you look at the
vertical hits at the left of the site the Zeitung
saves up a lot of space by putting 10 hits under
one hit. If you dont understand, take a
look. Theyve also got a very nice
orientation link. So you can see in the blink of
an eye what the site has got to offer. When you
choose the archive-hit you start by putting in a
word and after they find some hits you can also
look on date. Just to give you an idea of how
this site works we show you one example. When you
go to the movie hit, you can get information from
just about every big movie theatre in the
country. You can also give your vote about the
movie you have seen where the site gives
information about. We think its too bad
they didnt put any more time in writing
those articles.
4.
Prospects
Before we go to
DEFCON 2, we would like to acknowledge some
shortcomings that we ran into during this
project. First are the personal preferences that
influence ones evaluation of certain criteria. We
found that this became an evident problem for
which we couldnt cough up any substantial
measures, therefore we evaluated every
site at least three times by three different
groups/persons, summed up the values tied to the
specific criteria and split that outcome in the
amount of evaluations per site. That should solve
the problem.
Second is that
we ran into problems such as deviations on the
evaluation forms. Some pointed out that a certain
site had a discussion forum available, when
others couldnt find it. These kinds of
weaknesses are related to deadlines, motivation
and other sources of distraction. We pity this of
course, but would like to hear if the Groups in
Kalmar and Barcelona had similar troubles.
We also would
like to invite everyone for a critical look on
the way we worked, for a more effective structure
in phase two. And more feedback and discussion
regarding each groups progress is needed.
Notes: used
literature
ONLINE
JOURNALISTS: Foundations for Research into Their
Changing Roles, Jane B. Singer, Department of
Journalism and Technical Communication, Colorado
State University, http://www.ascusc.org/jcmc/vol4/issue1/singer.html
Results: The Kalmar Top
10
http://www.oneworld.net/front.shtml
Oneworld.net
reflects news from all over the world. The site
dedicated to promoting human rights and
sustainable development by harnessing the
democratic potential of the Internet. The sources
of the articles are given and longer
articles are linked. The sites structure is
logical and it is easily navigated. The site is
in english, but parts of it are available in
French, Dutch, Italian and German. The layout and
typo make it even more friendly for the users.
The site is not updated on weekends though. All
in all a favorit.
http://www.skynews.co.uk/skynews/
The site
has four frames. On top frame with the headlines
scrolling by. The left frame stays the same all
the time and here you find all categories,
finance, entertainment and so on. The right frame
has the different headlines for each section. The
big frame in the middle is where the article is.
The design is rather simple but works well. The
articles vary in length but are easy to read and
not to compact. Pictures in the text also help to
keep it light. The articles are layouted like
news paper articles which works well. The texts
are rather well written and broken up in very
short sections which makes it possible to read
them faster but looks bad. The site updates every
day. There are clear instructions at the bottom
on how owns the right to text and pictures and if
you want its easy to get in touch with Sky
on-line through pressing a button. There are a
few commercial banners but they are small and
rather still so they dont annoy you. The
site works very well but is slow when going
between categories and articles. I think this is
because the site has so many visitors.
http://www.newsnow.co.uk/
The
NewsNow site is actually a big links site. There
are several different categories, from business
and finance to entertainment. Under each category
there are several headlines. Each headline is a
link and takes you to a site were the actual
article can be found. After each headline there
is information on were the news comes from, when
it was updated and the nationality of the site,
e.g. BBC 16.10, English. Further information
about the source of information depends on which
site you come to. Often there is no author but a
lot of information on what kind of site it is.
The site really updates every 5 minutes and feel
very "right now". Since its a
completely English site all links go to sites in
English and all are either English or American.
When you press a link the article opens in a new
window which is good in this case. There are many
possibilities if you want to search. The archive
only goes 30 days back but theres a lot of
information. Along the left side of the screen
there is a navigation bar which never changes and
its here were you find the search function.
But there is also a special search for every
category, e.g. in the category you can search for
film revives or top 10 at the US box office.
Graphically the site is not very exciting.
Its just text but it serves its
purpose, there is so much information but
its so far no problem finding what you
want. There is only one commercial banner and
this keeps the site calm and functional. Since
its all just links all sound and moving
picture are found where ever the link takes you.
I feel that this decision is well made. Since
its all text I can find what I want quickly
and then the site I come to is where I stay a
long time and thats the site that needs to
be well designed, but the NewsNow site is a bit
boring looking. I dont know how they have
selected the sites that they link to but the
short time Ive been using the site i think
it works very well. If the quality on the sites
are although high and if it works as well as when
Ive been looking at it, I find this to bee
a very good news site.
http://www.scotsman.com/
Scotsman.com
is based on a paper but the site has its
own material and is updated 24 hours a day. The
articles are good, theyre written for the
site and the telegrams are few. The structure is
logical and the site is easiy to navigate. the
layout is a little different but thats one
of the reasons we liked the site. It is only
available in english and maybe it s a
little too focused on Scottish and UK news.
http://www.rte.ie/news/
This
site is interesting because it combines audio
& video clips with good news evaluation. The
owner of the site, Radio Telefís Éireann is the
Irish national broadcasting organisation. The
site is only in english but its focused
stretches out over more of Europe than Ireland.
It is updated on a daily basis, easy to navigate,
userfriendly. The arcive of articles, audio and
video clips is huge and well structured.
http://www.sbpost.ie/
Sunday
Bussiness Posts site is a Brittish site,
all in english. It is very easy to navigate,
logical, functunal, well structured and easy to
overview. The layout t is friendly, nice and kind
of different. The site contains almost only
articles, text, no pictures, so it is a fast
site. The archive goes way back and its
seeking functions are good.
http://www.berlingske.dk/
Berlingske
Tiderne is one of Denmarks largest
newspapers. The website, however, does not have
many similarities with the printed edition.
Its very adapted to the media, with a very
flashy lay-out. The text is splitted into many
paragraphs and rests on a grey backround, which
makes it very readable. The structure of the site
requires some figuring out, but once youre
done with that part its really good. Since
most of the material is produced by the
newspapers own employees, rather than assembled
from telegrams, there is no linking back to any
original material. There is also no sound or
video clips.
http://www.cnndanmark.dk/
CNNs
Danish site is adapted to the media in that way
that the articles are very short. This is not the
media to choose if you want deeper understanding
of major happenings, but if you want the most
important news fast its really good. The
navigation is very good. Everything is easy to
find. At the bottom of each article there is an
"external link"-box, containing related
links. Nice initiative. Too bad there almost
never are any links to find in that very box.
http://www.aftonbladet.se/
This
site has a very good reputation around Europe.
And I totally agree. The standard is very high.
Aftonbladet got everything. Good update on the
news, they got pictures -both stills and film
clip, the download is very fast. Besides all the
news they got good links. The site is very easy
to navigate. The typography is basic, nothing
exiting. To mention something negative about the
site. Its on Swedish only and it contain
adds. But since its a commercial site I
dont know if it is something to be negative
about, but it might lower the credibility. As a
final. aftonbladet.se is a really really good
site. One of our favourites.
http://www.dn.se/
Dn.se is
a copy of the Swedish newspaper Dagens Nyheter
(Todays News). DN has a clear level of
expectation, it is updated more than once a day,
but that isnt stated anywhere. The use of
interactivity is rare, only if a subject is
largely discussed in other Swedish media. Every
article is signed by the author, and it is
possible for the visitor to send e-mail with
thougts to the author of the article. DN is easy
navigated, with the major subjects to the left
(domestic, foreign, sports, economics and
culture) and the major headlines centered. DN is
a userfriendly site, with a good mixture of
design and functionality.
Results: The Spanish
Top 10
Radio Comercial
http://www.radiocomercial.pt
It can be heard live. It has a camera put on the
studio that lets you see what happens there every
2 mins. The web holds the program grid, and a
briefing of the most important daily news. It
also allows to see the traffic conditions through
two cameras in two different points of Lisboa.
One of the best we have found in Portugal.
Radio Deejay
http://www.deejay.it
Musical Radio owned by La Republica and
Espresso's mediatic group. It fulfils the
journalistic criteria. The design is fantastic
(no scroll recquired) and ergonomic. The music is
of the latest hour and has quality (good
selective criteria). There are no reception
technic problems. It uses all the posibilities
and plugs in the net: recovering of old programs,
music concert video clips, forum-chat, and plenty
of chances of two-way comunication. JUST TRY IT!
La Gazzeta dello
Sport
http://gazzetta.it/
This one also fulfils the journalistic
criteria... with a surprising twist. Throwing the
contents of a traditional (paper) media to the
web is the basic and, sometimes, easy idea of
"electronic press". La Gazzeta becomes
a publication specially created for the online
format. You'll find a sports newspaper, and from
the first page you'll find an absolutely
multi-media Gazetta: music, videoclips,
videogames, voices,...
TF1
http://www.tf1.fr
The webpage of TF1 fulfils the general criteria
(ethic, critical, plural, authentic and with
rigorous news). The digital version of this TV
channel has lots of thought-for-the-net
applications: documental file storing, live
Stocks, job and house finding services, advanced
search or by subject, the chance of sending news
and opinions, etc. It uses the latest material
and updates it periodically. It's a multimedia,
interactive media, plenty of store, with a simple
but catchy design, with a very fragmented image,
divided by colours. The offer seems to never end:
forums, chats, personal email, complaints sheet,
local weather forecasting, zodiacal forecasting,
teleshopping and more. At the same time it's fast
and easily browsable, although the only language
available is french.
Radio France
http://www.radio-france.fr
Radio France also fulfils all the general
criteria and also, despite having an original
conventional media, has a bunch of net specific
applications: old programs archives, the
possibility of live and à la carte radio,
thematic browser and personalization (even
setting an alarm to new information we are
interested into); they are open to opinions/news
and info about the sources, and has a shop of
product of their own brand. The informational
material is new and updated, interactive,
multimedia, extensive and very informative. The
web has a modern design, very colorful, lots of
animated gifs although, at the same time, is of
easy use and fast downloading. The only drawback,
like in most of the French press, is that
language can't be changed: français, rien ne
va plus.
Niçe Matin
http://www.nicematin.fr
The general and basic criteria are met. Its
design is fresh and new, and 100% interactive!
It's totally unrelated to its paper version,
although at the users will, a
"Text-only" version is available. Niçe
Matin is like a small TV screen that refreshes
every 10 seconds (that is, constant update).
Through this front page the other sections can be
accessed: the browsing is easy, as everything is
simplified to the top: it's a visual and fast
media. The informational capability is huge and
lots of serices are offered, like Stock Values,
forums, chats, search, personalized email,
documental archives, forecastings, etc. The only
dark point (you guessed): only-French media.
La Vanguardia
http://www.lavanguardia.com
Despite originally being a paper media, the easy
access of its contents, that allows to make
searches dated even 6 months in the past, and the
multiplicity of chances and services offered to
its readers (sending letters to the director,
press notes and even news) allows to put the web
of this newspaper (done by a different editorial
staff than the "paper" newspaper) as
one of the best in the country. This media allows
for personalize contents and to participate
through chats and on-line debates. Only in
spanish.
En.red.ando
http://enredando.com
Toughtful magazine that analyze the life in the
net. It has a personal design and high-interest
contents for the www user. It can be consulted in
spanish, catalan and, in most cases, also
english. Its creator is the El Periodico de
Catalunya's journalist Luis Ángel Fernández
Hermana.
La Malla
http://www.lamalla.net
One of the mediatic products of the Lavínia TV
firm, devoted to the local (catalan) information,
although also offers international news. It has
some sections really interesting, like the
reports one, or Sostenibilitat
("Sustaining"). It incorporates sound
and video, and has a good design labor. Its weak
spot is it's only in catalan.
Canal21
http://www.canal21.com
Visually original, with an impact hi-tech design
you will find in few journalistic webs.
Interactive doorway? Multimedia news? Uncompared
agenda? Canal21 is hard to describe, because it's
all that and many other things: weather
forecasts, personalization, chats, forums, local
news, global news, press reviews, cinema news,
email service, games... It even narrows its scale
of values when one of the autonomic communities
in Spain is chosen, even offering different
languages (catalan, euskera, galician) , thus
having catalan/basque/galician/... news and
services.
* Joan
Francesc Cánovas
es jefe de Estudios Estudios de Periodismo y y
responsable del curso Analising Digital
Journalism, en la Universidad Pompeu Fabra. Esta es su primera colaboración para Sala de Prensa. (NOTA DEL AUTOR: Este es un resumen del trabajo de
análisis de la asignatura Analising Digital
Journalism que hacemos las Universidades de Kalmar (Suecia), Zwolle (Holanda) y Pompeu Fabra en Barcelona. El estudio no se ha
publicado, pero este resumen nos sirvió para
nuestro propio uso. Lo elaboramos recopilando
distintos papers elaborados durante los trabajos
del curso. Por tanto, no tiene una misma unidad
gramatical, ni sintáctica. Actualmente estamos
realizando nuevamente el curso con las mismas
universidades pero con alumnos distintos.
Terminaremos en enero de 2001 y tendremos,
quizás, algunas nuevas conclusiones.)
|